There have been some amazing editorials in the Wall Street Journal recently. I know the Epstein article got everyone going, but it really is a sign of our times. We are living in a new secular Puritan age, at least that is how Gerard Baker eloquently described it.
For those of you who don’t remember who the Puritans were, they were “English Protestants in the 16th and 17th centuries who sought to purify the Church of England of Roman Catholic practices.” Eventually the term became a pejorative term identifying the group as extreme. “In current English, puritan often means against pleasure.” There is a plethora of information written about Puritans who came to the United States in the early 1600’s. The idea of Puritan hegemony “lasted about 100 years.” This time frame can be broken up into three sections: John Cotton and Richard Mather (1630-1662); Increase Mather (1162-1689); and Cotton Mather (1689-1728).
According to historians Puritans in the early colonies were industrious, believers in Education, an education based in the Bible, and would encourage people to think for themselves, “which is the basis of Democracy.” They were considered the most literate and taught their daughters to read. They also started Harvard University.
Many people only remember the controlling elements of early Puritanism. The Puritans believed “the state should protect and promote true religion and that religion should influence politics and social life.” They opposed Christmas celebrations as pagan, any Sunday sport or recreation, and no gambling. “Puritans condemned the sexualization of the theater and its associations with depravity and prostitution.” Anyone who has visited Salem, Massachusetts would have learned about the excesses associated with the prosecution of witches.
Our country has moved away from those early behaviors associated with the Puritans. In fact, if any of those early Puritans visited the U.S. today, I would imagine they would be appalled at what has evolved from their early labors. The early Puritans wanted to purge evil behavior from their community. They believed in the truth of the Bible, they recognized evil behavior was sin, and they believed that God defined what sin was and they were willing to live according to that eternal standard.
Today’s Puritans, interestingly enough, are, according to Baker, leftist progressives. I tend to agree with his premise. They are now the ones who are “extirpating sin from society.” The sin is not defined by the Bible but by their own defined leftist secular religion. And, if one does not agree with it, they will be figuratively dunked and stoned. The mob, which we have seen in full armor for four years, are not done and now are headed to new heights.
2020 was “the year that the long process of cultural indoctrination by the left wing’s establishment merged in perfect synergy with its authoritarian instinct to order people about.” The trifecta, see my last blog, has made advocacy the great reset using COVID-19 to establish foundational despotism all across this nation.
The politicians, academicians, journalists, and entertainers are telling us that Capitalism is racist and that the United States is racist to its core. If you don’t agree with this premise, then you will experience “an outpouring of self-lacerating racial-justice pietism.” These actions would make the Puritans seem permissive. It is almost like the new leftist puritans are telling the Puritans of the past, “you think you are judgmental, hold my beer.” Don’t get me wrong, Black Lives Matter, but I will not support the BLM organization. They have claimed to be Marxist and I cannot support that. Also, I am not saying that racism does not exist, it does and has, Therefore I will support my Black brothers and sisters in Christ, and others.
But my favorite comment from Baker put words to what I have been thinking. “The rules of the new theocracy,” the secular theology of leftist progressives, “also dictate that absolute deference to the unchallengeable authority of our leaders must coexist with moral license for them to do as they please.” This is why Biden can say, “you ain’t black if you don’t vote for me.” This is why the press can crucify Melania Trump, but when somebody writes something negative about Jill Biden, they go crazy. The trifecta controls all of the social narrative. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.
To add to my comments I want to draw attention to an incredible opinion piece today written by David Satter. “Soviet Politics, American Style” is an incredible expose` on the mob’s attempt to cancel anyone who is not adhering to what they think woke is. In his article Satter compares Wokeism with Marxism. He states, “It is true that Marxism is a more coherent system of thought than Wokeism. But even the intellectual hodgepodge can engender totalitarian habits if it fulfills an emotional need and becomes a device of interpretation.” The Wokeism of the left has done that.
What is really interesting is how Gorbachev warned the United States about what was going to happen to us. “We are going to do something terrible to you. We’re going to deprive you of an enemy.” Obviously, Russia is still an adversary; the recent hacking demonstrated that. But, not having an ideological enemy like the Soviet Union has sent us on a path of internal conflict. We must remember though the ideology of Marxism has never died. It is still alive and floating around the world. And many of the tactics used by the Soviet Union are still being used by the mob, even here in the United States.
First, there is “The transformation of tolerance into an ideology with its own courts, informers, and punishments, all are reminiscent of the Soviet Union.” Second, it is the now the philosophy of the news media to correct news not report it. This is similar to the Tass news service in the Soviet Union “which offered readers not news but a correct depiction of events.” Third, the Soviets were masters of liquidating academic freedom. If you were an academic in the Soviet Union, you taught what the state wanted you to teach. If anyone questioned what was being taught, a gulag was calling to them. Satter states, “The Soviet style has become a reality in the U.S. Speakers are routinely canceled on ideological grounds.”
Last, the encouragement of our own political leaders to blow the whistle on our neighbors during the holidays, if they had too many people at their homes, is horrific. Satter states, “The Soviet Union finally counted on the readiness of people to betray even family and friends.” The story was told of Pavel Morozov (1918-32) who lived in a small village in the Soviet Union. He found out his father was helping peasants hide grain from the authorities. “Pavel walked 35 miles to the nearest town to report him to the secret police.” I wonder how many people will be calling the police on their neighbors Friday? Oh, by the way, the father was arrested, and Pavel “was stabbed to death by relatives.”
I am an old man. I have written about the things I don’t like about what is happening in our communities and will continue to. But I worry about the new mob and the soft totalitarianism. I will probably be cancelled eventually. Maybe, one day I will stand before a tribunal much like in The Dark Night Rises and will have to choose exile or die, or die by exile.
And this is my thought for the day!